Jake Oettinger’s contract: What are the sticking points with the Dallas Stars?

Within the final exhibition of stars hockey, jake oettinger he was the star of the present. There have been “welcome to the NHL” moments: standing on its head in Colorado on February 15 both beating future Corridor of Famer Marc-Andre Fleury at Chicago on February 18, however a .954 save share in a seven-game playoff collection towards Calgary β€” and towards a pair of 100-point scorers whereas going through a Vezina finalist β€” I used to be the attribute introductory second.

That efficiency could not have come at a greater time for Oettinger, who entered the offseason as a restricted free agent on account of a brand new contract. Whereas Oettinger’s playoff efficiency heralded his arrival within the hockey world, there is no such thing as a new contract but, and that would trigger affordable concern with the opening of coaching camp subsequent month.

By all accounts, there was little dialogue between the 2 sides, regardless of either side making their emotions concerning the different very clear. In line with sources on either side, Oettinger, who entrusts his brokers with the enterprise facet and isn’t immediately concerned within the negotiations, desires to stick with the Stars. The Stars, who traded within the first spherical of the 2017 draft for Oettinger, consider he’s their future and don’t have any reservations about Oettinger as an individual.

What, then, is inflicting the useless finish?


One drawback is the shortage of comparable contracts. Of the 40 greatest goalkeepers in annual common values, starting from tortoiseshell value$10.5 million for Kaapo KahkΓΆnen$2.75 million, just one goalkeeper was as younger as Oettinger when he signed his contract. that goalkeeper is carter hart, who agreed to a three-year, $11.9 million ($3.979 million AAV) deal final summer time, simply days earlier than his twenty third birthday. Oettinger turned 23 on December 18.

Hart had a bigger displaying than Oettinger, beginning 95 video games in three seasons earlier than touchdown his contract. In his first two seasons, he had save percentages of .917 and .914 whereas beginning 30 and 40 video games, respectively. Nonetheless, within the season main as much as his summer time contract final yr, Hart had an .877 save share in 25 begins throughout the 56-game season.

In 2020-21, Oettinger began 24 video games as a rookie within the 56-game season and was the Stars’ greatest goaltender, posting a .911 save share and a 2.36 goals-against common. Regardless of being relegated to the AHL to begin the season, Oettinger began 46 video games final season and had a .914 save share, together with stretches wherein he served as among the finest goalies within the recreation. NHL and a major stretch late within the season the place he was requested to hold the All-Stars solely on account of a scarcity of choices behind him. He adopted that up with among the finest goalkeeping performances in NHL postseason historical past.

Oettinger is 25 fewer regular-season begins than Hart was when he signed final summer time, however he is basically the identical age and coming off a a lot better season and postseason. Hart’s $3.979 million is not the one knowledge level, however given the similarities in age and manufacturing, Hart is seen as a place to begin for what Oettinger deserves.

If $3.979 million is the baseline, how excessive does Oettinger’s quantity go? In the course of the 2020-21 season, Vancouver handed out fellow American goalie Thatcher Demko a five-year, $25 million contract for an AAV of $5 million. On the time Demko signed his contract, he was older than Oettinger in the present day (25 to 23), had a smaller pattern (59 begins to 70 begins), and had inferior profession statistics (.911 save share and .911 save share). from 2.92 GAA to .913). and a couple of.46 GAA).

The 13 netminders above the $5 million AAV mark are a number of the extra established gamers, many with Stanley Cup and/or Vezina issues. There have been quite a few different gamers thought of by the Oettinger workforce as compensation, however this pair of transactions from final yr present the place the valuation of a contract between $4 million AAV and round $5 million AAV comes into play.

Stars have their very own issues that make reaching that value considerably difficult. The primary is his wage cap state of affairs. Dallas has $11.4 million in cap house however has to slot in Oettinger and Jason Robertson, who’s coming off a runner-up season within the Calder Trophy and a 40-goal season to begin his NHL profession. robertson contract it’s going to undoubtedly be costlier than Oettinger’s. In line with one supply, these negotiations have had their very own obstacles.

If the Stars met Oettinger’s camp at his desired minimal value level, he would depart the workforce a little bit over $7 million to signal Robertson. That may nonetheless be sufficient for Robertson to signal a bridging deal, however barring a hometown low cost, a long-term deal would require greater than $8 million. Oettinger’s camp understands the Stars’ salary-cap state of affairs, together with the chance to doubtlessly money in 2025, however that will not lead to an enormous low cost.

The opposite issue for the Stars is warning. Arguably greater than every other place in hockey, the event path for goaltenders may be peculiar. Oettinger’s rookie season is an efficient instance of that. Oettinger didn’t get any votes from Calder, however six goalkeepers did within the 2020-21 season. Of these six, 4 are not on the workforce they performed for as rookies simply two seasons in the past. The opposite two guys completed within the high six within the Vezina voting final season, together with the 2022 winner Igor Shesterkin. Whereas the Stars have preferred what they’ve seen from Oettinger up to now, they’re tasked with ensuring they do not overreact to Calgary’s playoff collection, or simply the general pattern dimension of two seasons, one of many which was shortened.

The place the Stars’ precautionary rationale with Oettinger loses weight is that they’ve taken a cautious method with Oettinger, presumably to the purpose of failure, all through his younger profession to date. At each flip, Oettinger has overcome his fears. The Stars did not need Oettinger to play within the NHL in 2020-21, however bishop benThe damage state of affairs and lack of different choices compelled his hand. The workforce then needed to deal with Oettinger as No. 2, however Anton Khudobin’s struggles, coupled with Oettinger’s preparation for the NHL, led to him being given an even bigger position as a rookie.

Though Oettinger proved to have NHL caliber, the celebrities nonetheless needed to take it gradual. They signed Braden Holtby final summer time, which unofficially relegated Oettinger to the AHL, the place he would ultimately formally begin the season. As soon as Holtby’s damage and Khudobin’s ineffectiveness opened the door for Oettinger, he jumped on the probability.

In contract negotiations, participant and workforce are sometimes at odds with one another. In conditions like Oettinger and the Stars, there’s a frequent intention. Oettinger desires to be the most effective goalkeeper he may be; the celebrities need precisely the identical. The notion {that a} franchise that has been ravenous for a gifted younger goalie and moved as much as decide one within the first spherical of the draft does not need to set him up for achievement is a misplaced emotion. The Stars and Oettinger have simply executed issues in numerous methods.

Dallas has dealt with issues with warning and skepticism whereas Oettinger has dealt with issues with confidence. Oettinger’s confidence has held up up to now, on the ice. Now, the identical dynamic is in play on the negotiating desk.


Jake Oettinger. (Dennis Wierzbicki/USA Right this moment)

The place do issues go from right here?

In any contract negotiation, there are two details of battle: Time period and AAV. A supply mentioned Oettinger’s discipline is extensive open on the subject of time period. Oettinger desires to be in Dallas for the lengthy haul and if a long-term deal may be executed, that is nice. If the numbers recreation ends in a shorter provide, they’re open to that as effectively. The AAV is the place there is no such thing as a unconditional flexibility. Given the Stars’ salary-cap state of affairs, it is unlikely that Oettinger’s camp will have the ability to get precisely what they need, however they will not accept one thing they really feel is unfair relative to the market that is already been established.

A participant in Oettinger’s place, as a restricted free agent with no arbitration rights, is the place the workforce has essentially the most clout. A restricted free agent with arbitration rights or an unrestricted free agent are conditions the place the participant positive aspects extra affect on the workforce. Nonetheless, Oettinger is the primary goalie on the workforce and if the Stars began the season with Scott Wedgewood and Khudobin as a duo would clearly make a worse workforce than if Oettinger was within the image.

Whereas either side want to attain a decision as quickly as potential, the Stars are in no rush. Coaching camp begins in a month and a half and the season begins in simply over two months. These are the principle strain factors the place deadlines might result in a deal. Till then, there may be not a lot urgency. Nonetheless, that does not imply the timeline is not necessary. Given the Stars’ salary-cap state of affairs and Robertson’s looming contract, there’s an opportunity one other wrench may very well be thrown into the combination, and that is the potential for a suggestion sheet.

Supply sheets are a uncommon prevalence within the NHL, however so is the availability of gifted 23-year-old goaltenders who’ve proven potential to be franchise mainstays. If Robertson’s deal goes by means of first, he would give any workforce a agency quantity on how excessive they should go to place the Stars in a bind. At that time, the Stars can be compelled to shed gamers to create cap house to maintain Oettinger.

Whereas this looks as if a dangerous proposition, a Stars entrance workplace supply expressed no concern about potential provide sheets with Oettinger. For one factor, the participant additionally has to signal the provide sheet, and Oettinger has proven no indicators of being sad in Dallas. Second, the celebrities would have an opportunity to match, which they might do for any affordable tag. The one manner a workforce might actually harm the Stars or make them contemplate returning compensation can be if that workforce supplied Oettinger greater than $6.3 million AAV (a compensation package deal of first, second and third spherical picks). or greater than $8.4 million AAV (two first, one second, and one third-round decide compensation package deal).

A big and real looking risk to think about is a retention in coaching camp. As famous, Oettinger does not have a lot leverage on this state of affairs, however holding out can be one solution to put strain on the Stars.

Typically it simply takes one main breaking level to make issues work in a negotiation. That time has but to be reached between Oettinger and the Stars. Oettinger has been working as traditional this offseason, making ready at his dwelling in Minnesota for the upcoming season whereas his camp handles the enterprise facet.

(Jake Oettinger Prime Photograph: Dave Sandford/NHLI by way of Getty Photographs)

Leave a Comment